AAP - Car Safety Seats: A Guide for Families - 2002
Car Safety Seats: A Guide for Families
2002
American Academy of Pediatrics

Every state requires that infants and children ride buckled up. However, state laws do not always require the safest way to transport a child. More children are still killed as passengers in car crashes than from any other type of injury. Using a car safety seat correctly can help prevent injuries to young children, but it is not as easy as you think. Just a little mistake in how the seat is used could cause serious injury to your child.

Which is the "best" car safety seat?

Types of car safety seats
Infant-only seat

Infant-only seats

Infant-only seat features

Detachable base. Several infant-only seat models come with detachable bases. The base attaches to the car and the car safety seat easily snaps into the base. This way, you can carry your baby in and out of the car without needing to re-install the seat. After buckling your baby into the seat, you simply lock
Car seats and shopping carts
Do not place a child of any age in a shopping cart. Many infant-only car seats lock into shopping carts. Although infant seats may help prevent falls from shopping carts, injuries can still occur if the cart tips over. The weight of an infant in an infant seat placed high in a shopping cart may make the cart more top-heavy and more likely to tip over. This is true even for shopping carts with built-in infant seats. Thousands of children are hurt every year from falling from shopping carts or from the carts tipping over. Instead, use a backpack, front pack, or stroller while shopping.
the seat into the installed base. Some bases are adjustable to make it easier to correctly recline newborns. These seats also can be used without the base or you can buy additional bases for other cars. However, this feature is only helpful if the base fits tightly into your car. In some cases, the seat may fit better without the base.

Higher weight and height limits. Several infant-only seats are available for use up to 22 pounds, and at least one is available for use up to 35 pounds. Many convertible seats also now have higher weight and height limits in the rear-facing position for heavier or taller babies. Keep in mind that some babies may reach the top height limits of the seat before they reach the top weight limits. If your infant's weight or height exceeds the limits of the seat before a year, use an infant-only seat or a rear-facing convertible seat that has a higher limit.

Harness slots. Infant-only seats that come with more than one harness slot give more room for growing babies. In the rear-facing position, the harness slots usually should be at or below your baby's shoulders. Check the car safety seat manufacturer's instructions to be sure.

Handles. Carrying handles on car safety seats vary greatly in style and ease of use. Check the instructions for how to adjust the handle during travel.

Other features. Angle indicators, built-in angle adjusters, harness adjusters, and head support systems are other features that may make correct installation easier to achieve. See below for a list of infant-only seats.

Convertible seats

Note: If using a convertible seat for a small infant, the best choice for a more secure fit is the 5-point harness. A small baby's face can hit a shield in a crash.
Common questions about car seats
"What if my baby is premature?"
Use a car safety seat without a shield. Shields often are too high and too far from the body to fit correctly. A small baby's face could hit a shield in a crash. While still in the hospital, your baby should be observed in her car safety seat to make sure the semi-reclined position does not cause low heart rate, low oxygen, or other breathing problems. If your baby needs to lie flat during travel, use a crash-tested car bed. If possible, an adult should ride in the back seat next to your baby to watch him closely.
"What if my baby weighs more than 20 pounds but is not 1 year of age yet?"
There are now several infant-only and convertible seats that can be used rear-facing for children weighing more than 20 pounds. See the product listing below for specific seats.
"What if my child has special health care needs?"
Children with special health problems may need other restraint systems. Discuss this with your pediatrician. Easter Seals, Inc offers programs about car seat safety for children with special health care needs in the following states: California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Louisiana, Kentucky, New Mexico, Michigan, Missouri, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia. More information is available from Easter Seals, Inc at 800/221-6827.
For more information and a list of car safety seats available for children with special needs, see the AAP brochure, "Safe Transportation of Children with Special Needs: A Guide for Families."
"What if my car has air bags?"
Most new cars have air bags. When used with seat belts, air bags work very well to protect older children and adults. However, air bags are very dangerous when used with rear-facing car safety seats. If your car has a passenger air bag, infants in rear-facing seats must ride in the back seat. Even in a low-speed crash, the air bag can inflate, strike the car safety seat, and cause serious brain injury and death.
Toddlers who ride in forward-facing car safety seats also are at risk from air bag injuries. All children, even through school age, are safest in the back seat. If you must put an older child in the front seat, slide the vehicle seat back as far as it will go. Make sure your child is buckled and stays in the proper position at all times. This will help prevent the air bag from striking your child.
For most families, air bag on/off switches are not necessary. Air bags that are turned off cannot protect other passengers riding in the front seat. Air bag on/off switches only should be used if all of the following are true:
  • Your child has special health care needs.
  • Your pediatrician recommends constant supervision of your child during travel.
  • No other adult is available to ride in the back seat with your child.
    On/off switches also must be used if you have a vehicle with no back seat or a back seat that is not made for passengers.
    "What if my car has side air bags?"
    Side air bags improve safety for adults in side impact crashes. However, children who are seated near a front or rear side air bag can be at risk for serious injury. Refer to your vehicle owner's manual for recommendations that apply to your vehicle.
    "What if my car only has lap belts in the back seat?"
    Lap belts work fine with infant-only, convertible, and forward-facing seats. They cannot be used with belt-positioning boosters (which are safest for children who weigh more than 40 pounds and who are not big enough to fit in adult seat belts). If your car only has lap belts, use a forward-facing seat with a harness approved for use to higher weights, or check with your dealer or the manufacturer of your car to see if shoulder harnesses can be installed. Some travel vests can be used with lap belts. Another thing you can do is buy another car with lap/shoulder belts in the back seat.
    "What if I drive more children than can be buckled safely in the back seat?"
    Avoid this situation, especially if your car has passenger air bags. However, in an emergency, place the child most likely to sit in the proper forward-facing position in the front seat, with the vehicle seat moved as far back as possible. A child in a forward-facing car seat may be the best choice because a child who is in a booster seat or using a regular seat belt can more easily move out of position and be at greater risk for injuries from the air bag.
    "What if I lose my instructions to my car safety seat?"
    Call the manufacturer and ask for a new set of instructions.
    "What if my car safety seat was in a crash?"
    A seat that was in a crash may have been weakened and should not be used even if it looks fine. Call the car seat manufacturer if you have questions about the safety of your seat.
    "Can I use a car safety seat on an airplane?"
    The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the AAP recommend that children be securely fastened in child safety seats until 4 years of age, then be secured with the airplane seat belts. This will help keep them safe during takeoff and landing, or in case of turbulence. Most infant, convertible, and forward-facing seats are certified to be used on airplanes. Booster seats and travel vests are not. Check the label on your seat and call the airline before you travel to be sure your seat meets current FAA regulations.
  • Convertible seat features

    Adjustable buckles and shields . Many convertible seats have 2 or more buckle positions to give you extra room for a growing child or bulky clothing. Many overhead shields can be adjusted as well.

    Higher weight limits. Several convertible seats are now available with higher rear-facing weight limits for bigger babies. For larger babies, look for a seat that can be used rear-facing up to 30 or 35 pounds.

    See below for a list of convertible seats.

    Combination seats

    See below for a list of combination seats.

    Forward-facing seats/restraints

    See below for a list of forward-facing seats/restraints.

    Booster seats
    High-backed belt-
    positioning booster

    When your child reaches the top weight allowed for his car safety seat or his ears have reached the top of his car safety seat, your child needs a booster seat. Booster seats should be used until your child can correctly use a lap/shoulder seat belt (see below for information on using seat belts). Following are 2 types of booster seats:

    Children who weigh 40 pounds or less are best protected in a seat with a full harness. Significant injuries have occurred to children in shield boosters in crashes due to ejection, excessive head movement, and shield contact. Although boosters with shields may meet current Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards for use by children who weigh 30-40 pounds, on the basis of current published peer-reviewed data, the AAP does not recommend their use. Children should remain in a convertible, forward-facing, or combination seat with a full harness until they reach the top weight or height allowed by the seat.

    See below for a list of booster seats.

    Travel vests

    A travel vest may be an option if your car has only lap belts.

    See below for a list of travel vests.

    Built-in seats (integrated seats)

    Built-in seats are available in some cars and vans. They may be used for children who are at least 1 year of age and weigh at least 20 pounds. Built-in seats eliminate installation problems. However, weight and height limits vary. Check with vehicle manufacturers for details about built-in seats that are currently available.

    Basics of car safety seat use

    Using car safety seats correctly

    Read the car safety seat manufacturer's instructions and the child restraint section of your vehicle owner's manual carefully to be sure you are installing and using the car safety seat correctly. When you install the seat in your car, check the following:

    Is your child buckled into the car safety seat correctly?

    Is the car safety seat buckled into your vehicle correctly?

    What is LATCH?

    A new car safety seat attachment system has been developed to make car safety seats easier to use and safer. The system is called LATCH, which stands for Lower Anchors and Tethers for Children. This new anchor system will make correct installation much easier because you will no longer need to use seat belts to secure the car safety seat. Starting in model year 2002, most new vehicles and new safety seats will be equipped with these lower anchors and attachments. However, unless both the vehicle and the car safety seat have this new anchor system, seat belts will still be needed to secure the car safety seat.

    Why are tethers important?

    Most new car safety seats that can be used facing forward come with top tethers. A tether is a strap that hooks the top of the car safety seat to a special permanent anchor in the vehicle. Most anchors are located on the rear window ledge, the back of the vehicle seat, or the floor or ceiling of the vehicle. Tethers give extra protection by keeping the car safety seat from being thrown forward in a crash.

    Tether kits are available for most older car safety seats. Check with the car safety seat manufacturer to find out how to get a top tether for your seat. Be sure to install it according to instructions. The tether strap may help make some seats that are difficult to install fit more tightly.

    All new cars, minivans, and light trucks have been required to have upper tether anchors for securing the tops of car safety seats since September 2000.

    For specific information about installing your car safety seat, you may consult a certified Child Passenger Safety (CPS) Technician. CPS Technicians are certified by the American Automobile Association (AAA). A list of certified CPS Technicians is available by state or ZIP code on the NHTSA Web site at: http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/people/injury/childps/Contacts/index.cfm
    A list of inspection stations staffed by certified CPS Technicians is available at: http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/people/injury/childps/CPSFitting/Index.cfm
    The information is available by telephone on the NHTSA Auto Safety Hot Line at 888/DASH-2-DOT (888/327-4236), from 8 am to 10 pm ET, Monday through Friday.

    Is your child ready for a regular seat belt?

    Keep your child in a car safety seat for as long as possible. When your child is big enough, make sure the seat belts in your vehicle fit your child correctly. The shoulder belt should lie across the chest, not the neck or throat. The lap belt must be low and snug across the thighs, not the stomach. The child should sit against the vehicle seat back with her feet hanging down when the legs are bent at the knee. Seat belts are made for adults. If the seat belt does not fit your child correctly, she should stay in a booster seat until the belt fits. This is usually when the child reaches about 4' 9" in height and is between 8-12 years of age.

    Other points to keep in mind when using seat belts include the following:

    There are a number of add-on products on the market that claim to solve the problem of poorly fitting seat belts. However, these products may actually interfere with proper lap and shoulder belt fit by causing the lap belt to ride too high on the abdomen and making the shoulder belt too loose. Until the NHTSA develops standards for these products, the AAP recommends they not be used.

    Are you using a second-hand seat? Double-check everything!

    A new car safety seat is best. However, if you must get a used seat, shop very carefully. Keep the following points in mind:

    Do not use a car safety seat that

    Has the car safety seat been recalled?
    You can find out by calling the manufacturer or the Auto Safety Hot Line at 888/DASH-2-DOT (888/327-4236), from 8 am to 10 pm ET, Monday through Friday. This information is also available on the NHTSA Web site at:
    http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/problems/recalls/index.cfm
    If the seat has been recalled, be sure to follow instructions to fix it or get the necessary parts. You also may get a registration card for future recall notices from the hot line.

    ALWAYS READ AND FOLLOW MANUFACTURER'S INSTRUCTIONS
    If you do not have the car safety seat manufacturer's instructions, write or call the company's consumer relations department, identifying the model number, name of seat, and date of manufacture. The manufacturer's address and phone number may be on the label on the seat.
    All products listed below meet Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 213 as of the date of publication. There may be car safety seats available that are not listed on this page. The following information is current as of the date of publication. Before purchasing a car safety seat, check the manufacturer's instructions for important safety information about proper fitting and use.

    Manufacturers names are boldfaced.

    Infant-only seats
    NameHarness TypeRear-Facing
    Weight Limits
    Height Limits
    (when available)
    Price
    Britax Handle With Care5-point5-20 pounds19" to 26"$140-$150
    Car Seat Specialty Baby One5-point5-22 poundsTop of head is 1" from top of seat$36-$40
    Century Assura 223-point20 poundsUp to 27"$40
    Century Celestia/Vante3-point/5-point22 pounds29"$60-$80
    Century Smart Fit Plus 22,
    Smart Fit Plus 22 V
    3-point/5-point22 poundsUp to 27"$50-$60
    Century Smart Fit Supreme5-point22 poundsUp to 29"$80-$90
    Cosco Arriva3-point/5-point5-22 pounds26"$30-$40
    Cosco Designer 223-point5-22 pounds26"$60-$70
    Cosco Designer 355-point5-35 pounds35"$70-$80
    Cosco TLC3-point5-20 pounds26"$20-$25
    Cosco Ultra Dream Ride
    Infant Car Seat/Car Bed
    3-point5-20 pounds26"$50
    Evenflo Cozy Carry 3 / Cozy Carry 53-point/5-point22 poundsUp to 29 1/2" - Top of head should be 1" below top of seat$60-$90
    Evenflo Discovery AR3-point20 poundsTop of head should be 1" below top of seat$50
    Evenflo Discovery ARV5-point20 poundsTop of head should be 1" below top of seat$60
    Evenflo On My Way
    Position Right
    5-point20 poundsTop of head should be 1" below top of seat$70-$80
    Graco SnugRide3-point20 poundsUp to 26"$45-$60
    Graco SnugRide DX55-point20 poundsUp to 26"$70
    Graco SnugRide LX55-point20 poundsUp to 26"$80-$90

    Convertible seats
    NameHarness TypeRear-Facing
    Weight Limits/
    Height Limits
    Forward-Facing
    Weight Limits/
    Height Limits
    Price
    Britax Advantage5-point5-30 pounds
    19"-30"
    20-40 pounds
    27"-40"
    $230-$250
    Britax Roundabout5-point5-30 pounds
    19"-30"
    20-40 pounds
    27"-40"
    $200-$209
    Car Seat Specialty Safety Basic5-point30 pounds22-40 pounds$48-$58
    Century 1000 STE5-point22 pounds20-40 pounds$50
    Century Accel5-point
    Overhead shield
    30 pounds20-40 pounds
    40"
    $60-$80
    Century Bravo Series5-point30 pounds20-40 pounds
    40"
    $100-$130
    Century Encore5-point
    Overhead shield
    30 pounds20-40 pounds
    40"
    $80-$90
    Century Room to GrowOverhead shield22 pounds20-40 pounds$60
    Century Smart Move5-point30 pounds20-40 pounds
    40"
    $90-$120
    Cosco Alpha Omega
    (rear-facing, forward-facing,
    or booster)
    5-point
    Overhead shield
    5-35 pounds22-40 pounds
    30-80 pounds as
    belt-positioning
    booster
    40"
    $130
    Cosco Forerunner Single Belt Latch Seat5-point5-35 pounds22-40 pounds
    40"
    $70
    Cosco Olympian5-point
    Overhead shield
    5-35 pounds22-40 pounds
    40"
    $60-$70
    Cosco Touriva5-point
    Overhead shield
    5-35 pounds22-40 pounds
    40"
    $30-$50
    Evenflo Conquest I, V5-point
    Overhead shield
    30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $50-$60
    Evenflo Horizon IOverhead shield30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $80
    Evenflo Horizon V5-point30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    22-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $70
    Evenflo Medallion VCT5-point30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $109
    Evenflo Secure Advantage
    I, V, VCT, ICT
    5-point
    Overhead shield
    30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $80-$100
    Evenflo Odyssey V,
    VCT, I, ICT
    5-point
    Overhead shield
    30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $80-$100
    Evenflo Titan 5, Titan 5 CT, Titan OHS CT, Titan OHS5-point
    Overhead shield
    30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $60-$80
    Evenflo Triumph CT5-point30 pounds
    Top of head should be 1" below top of seat
    20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $130-$140
    Safeline Sit 'n Stroll5-point5-22 pounds20-40 pounds$199

    Combination seats
    (Can be used with 5-point harness or as belt-positioning booster.)
    NameWeight Limits/
    Height Limits
    With Harness
    Weight Limits/
    Height Limits as
    Belt Positioner
    Price
    Car Seat Specialty Airway22-50 pounds33-80 pounds$65-$75
    Car Seat Specialty Speedway22-40 pounds
    Until child's ears are higher than head rest
    33-80 pounds
    Until child's ears are higher than head rest
    $46-$56
    Century Breverra Classic,
    Transit, Metro, Ascend SE, Ascend DX
    30-40 pounds30-80 pounds$45-$90
    Century Next Step Stage II20-40 pounds30-80 pounds$80-$100
    Cosco High Back Booster,
    Adventurer II High Back Booster
    22-40 pounds30-80 pounds
    51" as long as midpoint of head is below seat back
    $40-$70
    Cosco Vantage Point, Summit22-40 pounds30-100 pounds
    51" as long as midpoint of head is below seat back
    $80-$100
    Cosco Vista, Ventura, Commuter22-40 pounds30-80 pounds
    51" as long as midpoint of head is below seat back
    $40-$70
    Evenflo Apollo20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    30-80 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $100
    Evenflo Express, Express CT20-40 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    30-80 pounds
    Child's ears should not be above top of car seat
    $50-$60
    Graco Grand CarGo20-40 pounds
    27"-40"
    30-80 pounds
    35"-54"
    $60
    Graco Treasured CarGo20-40 pounds
    27"-40"
    30-80 pounds
    35"-54"
    $50
    Graco Ultra CarGo20-40 pounds
    27"-40"
    30-80 pounds
    35"-54"
    $70

    Forward-facing seats/restraints
    NameHarness TypeBelt TypeWeight LimitsHeight LimitsPrice
    Britax Expressway5-pointLap only belt or
    lap/shoulder belt
    20-40 pounds27"-40"$170-$180
    Britax Super Elite5-pointLap only belt or
    lap/shoulder belt
    22-80 pounds19"-53"$199
    Britax LaptopNoneLap only belt or
    lap/shoulder belt
    30-65 pounds33"-51"$50

    Booster seats*
    NameTypeWeight LimitsHeight Limits
    (when available)
    Price
    Basic Comfort Galaxy 2000High back
    Low back
    30-70 pounds
    40-70 pounds
    $60
    $25
    Britax RoadsterHigh back40-100 pounds33"-56"$100-$110
    Britax Star Riser/ComfyLow back
    High back
    30-80 pounds33"-53"$49
    $119
    Car Seat Specialty Duo Highback BP BoosterHigh back
    Low back
    30-80 poundsUntil child's ears are higher than head rest$35-$40
    Car Seat Specialty HighRide BP BoosterLow back33-80 poundsUntil child's ears are higher than head rest$20-$25
    Car Seat Specialty Topper BP BoosterHigh back
    Low back
    33-80 poundsUntil child's ears are higher than head rest$40-$50
    Century Breverra SportHigh back30-80 pounds $30-$40
    Century Breverra Ascend SportHigh back30-80 pounds $50
    Cosco Grand ExplorerShield
    Low back
    30-40 pounds with shield
    40-80 pounds as belt positioner
    Midpoint of head
    below top of seat
    $25
    Cosco Complete VoyagerHigh back30-80 pounds51" as long as midpoint
    of head is below seat back
    $30
    Evenflo Right FitLow back40-80 pounds $25
    Evenflo SightseerHigh back40-80 poundsChild's ears should not be above top of seat back.$30-$40
    Graco My CarGoHigh back30-80 pounds35"-54"$60
    Jupiter Komfort Rider GTX Belt-Positioning SeatHigh back33-100 pounds37"-60"$99
    Jupiter Komfort Rider GT
    Belt-Positioning Seat
    High back33-90 pounds37"-51"$79
    Jupiter Komfort Kruiser Belt-Positioning SeatHigh back with
    recline feature
    33-100 pounds37"-60"$119
    Polo Booster Seat
    (Car Seat Specialty, Inc and Safety Angel, Inc)
    Low back30-80 poundsUntil child's ears are
    higher than head rest
    $16-$20
    Uno Booster Seat
    (Car Seat Specialty, Inc and Safety Angel, Inc)
    Low back30-80 poundsUntil child's ears are
    higher than head rest
    $20-$30
    * Although boosters with shields may meet current Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards for use by children who weigh 30-40 pounds, on the basis of current published peer-reviewed literature, the American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend their use.

    Travel vests
    NameWeight Limits/Age LimitsPrice
    Cosco Tote 'n Go25-40 pounds with harness$20
    E-Z-On Vest20-164 pounds$120
    E-Z-On Modified Vest20-100 pounds
    2-12 years of age
    $120-$140
    E-Z-On Universal 86Y40-164 pounds
    4 years of age and up
    $60-$80

    Built-in (integrated) seats
    Built-in or integrated child safety seats now are available on selected models from some motor vehicle manufacturers. Check with the manufacturers for specifics.

    Although the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) is not a testing or standard setting organization, this guide sets forth the Academy's recommendations based upon the peer reviewed literature available at the time of its publication and sets forth some of the factors that parents should consider before selecting and using a car safety seat.
    The appearance of the name American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) does not constitute a guarantee or endorsement of the products listed or the claims made.
    Prices are approximate and may vary.
    The information contained in this publication should not be used as a substitute for the medical care and advice of your pediatrician. There may be variations in treatment that your pediatrician may recommend based on individual facts and circumstances.

    ? 2002 - American Academy of Pediatrics